Skip to content

First We Take Manhattan

Leonard Cohen
Popularity ยท Top

Listen

YouTube

0:00 / 0:00
Loading YouTube player...
Lyrics offset
Synced

Lyrics

Lyrics meaning

The speaker describes himself as someone punished for trying to change an unjust system, and now preparing to strike back. The repeated plan to take two cities sounds like a campaign of conquest, but it may be symbolic rather than literal. His tone shifts between determined, threatening, and strangely intimate: he wants closeness with a lover even as he presents himself as a dangerous force.

Several images make his motives feel unstable. He says he is guided by a heavenly signal and a birthmark, suggesting he sees his mission as fate or a personal destiny. Calling weapons beautiful hints at how violence has become attractive to him. The โ€œlineโ€ moving through the station may suggest a group, movement, or threat approaching; his claim to be โ€œone of thoseโ€ is deliberately unclear. The monkey and plywood violin sound like mocking or inadequate gifts, which he says he has turned into practice.

The lyrics can be heard as a revenge fantasy, a satire of political certainty, or a portrait of someone mixing private hurt with grand plans. His complaints about fashion, drugs, and his sister point to specific grievances, but the song does not explain them fully. Even the final image of everyone being wounded leaves open whether the speaker sees himself as a liberator, a victim, or another source of harm.